The Big Think

December 31, 2008

Lack of Skepticism

Filed under: Politics — jasony @ 6:33 pm

If there is a central problem with journalism, it is the lack of skepticism. Especially as it applies to government. Politicians and political organizations are not held to account for contradictory statements, false predictions and claims…

The Right has convinced itself that the problem is “that liberal media”, but that is obstructive rhetoric. Sure, there are a multitude of examples of media bias that favors the Left…but there are also a multitude of examples of media bias that favors the Right. People notice what they expect to see.

This isn’t a problem of personal bias; biases are unavoidable and don’t fit a left/right matrix, anyway. Ultimately, criticisms of Left/Right bias are tactical attacks against symptoms, not the problem itself. Crying “that liberal media!” delegitimizes our more fundamental criticisms.

The problem isn’t a biased media. It is a media that has lost sight of the role of journalism and reporters.

If there is even a question of whether they should be extremely skeptical of political claims, then they aren’t really a Fourth Estate at all. They’ve just become enablers of the Estates to which they are attached.

full article here.

1 Comment »

  1. Yes! I completely agree. That’s why I like watching The Daily Show for news because they actually show how foolish politicians sound if you compare what they said now vs what they said a week or a month or a year ago.

    Comment by greg — January 2, 2009 @ 10:29 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Powered by WordPress